The Gospel Truth about Housing


This is big news.  The Freedom from Religion Foundation in the process of suing the federal government for its religious housing allowance.  Unfortunately, the suit was challenged on the grounds that complaintants had no standing, so it was being held up before it even started.

The “good news” is that judge, in response, basically said: You have to be kidding.

U.S. District Judge Barbara Crabb, Western District of Wisconsin, issued a strong 20-page opinion and order today permitting FFRF Co-Presidents Dan Barker and Annie Laurie Gaylor and President Emerita Anne Gaylor to pursue their challenge of the 1954 law.

Known as FFRF v. USA, the lawsuit was filed in September 2011. The plaintiffs receive part of their salaries designated for a housing allowance. Yet they do not qualify for the parish exemption as they are not “ministers of the gospel.”

Dan Barker, in an earlier career was as a minister of the gospel and was able to get the parish exemption.  His current position, as co-president the FFRF, includes a housing allowance,  but does not qualify for parish exemption.  Why should one non-profit leadership position (in a church) be given a parish exemption, but another leadership position (not in a church) not?  Are churches somehow different than any other non-profit? Doesn’t giving special rights to ministers of the gospel violate the 1st Amendment? It seems clear that exemptions should either extend to “non-prophet” organizations or be removed altogether.

The unique benefits to clergy date to 1954, when Congress amended the tax code to permit all clergy to exempt their housing costs from their taxable income. U.S. Rep. Peter Mack, author of the amendment, declared:

“Certainly, in these times when we are being threatened by a godless and antireligious world movement we should correct this discrimination against certain ministers of the gospel who are carrying on such a courageous fight against this foe. Certainly this is not too much to do for these people who are caring for our spiritual welfare.”

Clearly, the parish exemption  is a McCarthy-era law that needs to be looked at very closely.  If overturned will go a long way to equality in the law for the nonreligious.  So, thank you, Judge Crabb, for letting this case go forward.

Note: The post has been updated for clarity.

About these ads

About SamStone

A Steel City Skeptic who thinks science and reason is the light that we should follow to find our way in this world.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to The Gospel Truth about Housing

  1. Robert Baty says:

    Indeed, it is big news!
    It’s a big story!
    And yet the mainstream media has yet to pick up on it, or are deliberately ignoring it.
    Romney and Obama need to be compelled to speak to the issue.
    Why is the Obama Justice Department trying to defend the law?
    What would a Romney Justice Department do?
    Why hasn’t Congress and the President acted to cure what ails IRC 107?
    They had the chance when Rick Warren’s case was before the Court and chose to preserve the law and all of its abuses. They had the chance when Senator Grassley investigated those million dollar ministries.
    No political will has been demonstrated to cure what ails IRC 107.
    May the FFRF IRC 107 Challenge proceed speedily through the courts and may each subsequent ruling be in favor of the FFRF.
    I look for a summary judgment concluding that, as claimed, IRC 107 is UNconstitutional on its face.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s